Проблема спящего режима N + 1 с двунаправленным сопоставлением OneToOne

Question

Я использую JPARepository с hibernate для представления своей базы данных. У меня есть несколько сущностей, и две из моих сущностей имеют двунаправленное отображение OneToOne. Всякий раз, когда я запускаю запрос к дочернему классу двунаправленных отношений (или родительскому классу, чтобы получить дочерний класс) - я сталкиваюсь с проблемой гибернации N + 1.

Моя родительская сущность:

@Entity
@Table(name = "ORGANIZATION")
public class Organization {

    @GeneratedValue(strategy = GenerationType.IDENTITY)
    @Column(name = "id", nullable = false)
    @Id
    private Long id;

    @OneToOne(fetch = FetchType.EAGER)
    @JoinColumn(name = "organization_source_id")
    private OrganizationSource source;

    //other columns then getters and setters
}

Детский класс

@Entity
@Table(name = "ORGANIZATION_SOURCE")
public class OrganizationSource {

    @GeneratedValue(strategy = GenerationType.IDENTITY)
    @Column(name = "id", nullable = false)
    @Id
    private Long id;

    @OneToOne(mappedBy="source", fetch = FetchType.LAZY)
    @Cascade(value=org.hibernate.annotations.CascadeType.SAVE_UPDATE)
    private Organization organization;

    //other columns then getters and setters
}

Затем у меня есть класс DAO для создания запроса. Я использовал аннотацию @Query

public interface OrganizationSourceDao extends PagingAndSortingRepository<OrganizationSource, Long> {



@Query("SELECT source FROM OrganizationSource source RIGHT JOIN source.organization"
            + "WHERE source.name like %:name% "
    //   order by part of the query
    )
    Page<OrganizationSource> findByNameContaining(
            @Param("name") String name,
            @PageableDefault(size = 10) Pageable pageable);
    }

Выполнение запроса в DAO показывает следующее в журнале

Hibernate: select organizati0_.id as id1_6_, organizati0_.city as city2_6_, organizati0_.code as code3_6_, organizati0_.name as name4_6_, organizati0_.source_system_id as source_s5_6_, organizati0_.state as state6_6_, organizati0_.street as street7_6_, organizati0_.uuid as uuid8_6_, organizati0_.zip as zip9_6_ from organization_source organizati0_ right outer join organization organizati1_ on organizati0_.id=organizati1_.organization_source_id where (organizati0_.name like ?) and (organizati0_.state like ?) and (organizati0_.city like ?) order by case ? when 'ASC' then case ? when 'name' then organizati0_.name when 'state' then organizati0_.state when 'city' then organizati0_.city when 'zip' then organizati0_.zip when 'street' then organizati0_.street end end ASC, case ? when 'DESC' then case ? when 'name' then organizati0_.name when 'state' then organizati0_.state when 'city' then organizati0_.city when 'zip' then organizati0_.zip when 'street' then organizati0_.street end end DESC offset 0 rows fetch next ? rows only
Hibernate: select organizati0_.id as id1_4_1_, organizati0_.mfa_method_id as mfa_meth4_4_1_, organizati0_.organization_source_id as organiza5_4_1_, organizati0_.status_id as status_i6_4_1_, organizati0_.uuid as uuid2_4_1_, organizati0_.version as version3_4_1_, organizati1_.id as id1_6_0_, organizati1_.city as city2_6_0_, organizati1_.code as code3_6_0_, organizati1_.name as name4_6_0_, organizati1_.source_system_id as source_s5_6_0_, organizati1_.state as state6_6_0_, organizati1_.street as street7_6_0_, organizati1_.uuid as uuid8_6_0_, organizati1_.zip as zip9_6_0_ from organization organizati0_ left outer join organization_source organizati1_ on organizati0_.organization_source_id=organizati1_.id where organizati0_.organization_source_id=?
Hibernate: select organizati0_.id as id1_4_1_, organizati0_.mfa_method_id as mfa_meth4_4_1_, organizati0_.organization_source_id as organiza5_4_1_, organizati0_.status_id as status_i6_4_1_, organizati0_.uuid as uuid2_4_1_, organizati0_.version as version3_4_1_, organizati1_.id as id1_6_0_, organizati1_.city as city2_6_0_, organizati1_.code as code3_6_0_, organizati1_.name as name4_6_0_, organizati1_.source_system_id as source_s5_6_0_, organizati1_.state as state6_6_0_, organizati1_.street as street7_6_0_, organizati1_.uuid as uuid8_6_0_, organizati1_.zip as zip9_6_0_ from organization organizati0_ left outer join organization_source organizati1_ on organizati0_.organization_source_id=organizati1_.id where organizati0_.organization_source_id=?
Hibernate: select organizati0_.id as id1_4_1_, organizati0_.mfa_method_id as mfa_meth4_4_1_, organizati0_.organization_source_id as organiza5_4_1_, organizati0_.status_id as status_i6_4_1_, organizati0_.uuid as uuid2_4_1_, organizati0_.version as version3_4_1_, organizati1_.id as id1_6_0_, organizati1_.city as city2_6_0_, organizati1_.code as code3_6_0_, organizati1_.name as name4_6_0_, organizati1_.source_system_id as source_s5_6_0_, organizati1_.state as state6_6_0_, organizati1_.street as street7_6_0_, organizati1_.uuid as uuid8_6_0_, organizati1_.zip as zip9_6_0_ from organization organizati0_ left outer join organization_source organizati1_ on organizati0_.organization_source_id=organizati1_.id where organizati0_.organization_source_id=?
Hibernate: select organizati0_.id as id1_4_1_, organizati0_.mfa_method_id as mfa_meth4_4_1_, organizati0_.organization_source_id as organiza5_4_1_, organizati0_.status_id as status_i6_4_1_, organizati0_.uuid as uuid2_4_1_, organizati0_.version as version3_4_1_, organizati1_.id as id1_6_0_, organizati1_.city as city2_6_0_, organizati1_.code as code3_6_0_, organizati1_.name as name4_6_0_, organizati1_.source_system_id as source_s5_6_0_, organizati1_.state as state6_6_0_, organizati1_.street as street7_6_0_, organizati1_.uuid as uuid8_6_0_, organizati1_.zip as zip9_6_0_ from organization organizati0_ left outer join organization_source organizati1_ on organizati0_.organization_source_id=organizati1_.id where organizati0_.organization_source_id=?
Hibernate: select organizati0_.id as id1_4_1_, organizati0_.mfa_method_id as mfa_meth4_4_1_, organizati0_.organization_source_id as organiza5_4_1_, organizati0_.status_id as status_i6_4_1_, organizati0_.uuid as uuid2_4_1_, organizati0_.version as version3_4_1_, organizati1_.id as id1_6_0_, organizati1_.city as city2_6_0_, organizati1_.code as code3_6_0_, organizati1_.name as name4_6_0_, organizati1_.source_system_id as source_s5_6_0_, organizati1_.state as state6_6_0_, organizati1_.street as street7_6_0_, organizati1_.uuid as uuid8_6_0_, organizati1_.zip as zip9_6_0_ from organization organizati0_ left outer join organization_source organizati1_ on organizati0_.organization_source_id=organizati1_.id where organizati0_.organization_source_id=?
Hibernate: select organizati0_.id as id1_4_1_, organizati0_.mfa_method_id as mfa_meth4_4_1_, organizati0_.organization_source_id as organiza5_4_1_, organizati0_.status_id as status_i6_4_1_, organizati0_.uuid as uuid2_4_1_, organizati0_.version as version3_4_1_, organizati1_.id as id1_6_0_, organizati1_.city as city2_6_0_, organizati1_.code as code3_6_0_, organizati1_.name as name4_6_0_, organizati1_.source_system_id as source_s5_6_0_, organizati1_.state as state6_6_0_, organizati1_.street as street7_6_0_, organizati1_.uuid as uuid8_6_0_, organizati1_.zip as zip9_6_0_ from organization organizati0_ left outer join organization_source organizati1_ on organizati0_.organization_source_id=organizati1_.id where organizati0_.organization_source_id=?

Я смотрел на использование аннотации @Fetch(FetchMode.JOIN) и всех тех, кто быстро решает проблемы, доступные в Google, - похоже, не могу решить эту проблему.

Любая помощь будет высоко ценится.

Answer 1

Я знаю один трюк. Изменить отображение организации с OneToOne на ManyToOne. Это прекрасно работает все время для меня. НЕТ n + 1 запрос на этот раз.

OrganizationSource

@Entity
@Table(name = "ORGANIZATION_SOURCE")
public class **OrganizationSource** {

 @GeneratedValue(strategy = GenerationType.IDENTITY)
 @Column(name = "id", nullable = false)
 @Id
 private Long id;

 @JsonBackReference
 @Cascade(value=org.hibernate.annotations.CascadeType.SAVE_UPDATE)
 @ManyToOne(fetch = FetchType.LAZY)
 private Organization organization;

 private String name;
}

И Организация

@Data
@Entity
@Table(name = "ORGANIZATION")
public class Organization {

 @GeneratedValue(strategy = GenerationType.IDENTITY)
 @Column(name = "id", nullable = false)
 @Id
 private Long id;

 @JsonManagedReference
 @OneToOne(fetch = FetchType.EAGER)
 @JoinColumn(name = "organization_source_id")
 private OrganizationSource source;

}